To be honest, I have little confidence in my characterization. But since I don’t have to worry about being “right”, here I start.
In “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” and “My Last Duchess”, both poem is the story that told by a speaker, also monologues.
However, I find speaker in “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” is speaking directly to audience (Me), and speaker in “My Last Duchess” is speaking to other person. The 12th line in “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” gave me evidence that he is talking directly to audience. And 5th line of ”My Last Duchess” clearly shows that speaker is talking to another person.
Well, I will characterize J. Alfred Prufrock first, who is the speaker of the T.S Eliot’s poem. J. Alfred Prufrock is a male, with a bald spot in the middle of his hair (line 39). And he also has various mental problems. He believes that he is some kind of devil or creepy being, in the very beginning of the poem, he talks about it. And he keeps imagining, or guessing about other people’s reaction, especially lady’s reaction to his questions. He is actually talking to himself, because he is assuming all the answers and responses of others. Also, he has extremely low self esteem on himself. All the evidences can be seen in lines 40, 43, 44 and 45. And in line 45, the word ‘universe’ indicates the room, where the poem takes place. Lastly, he is justifying himself that why he didn’t talk and sing a song for lady and already assume that it won’t worth the effort. In line 110, he is comparing him with Hamlet, dramatizing situation he putted into. Overall, I think J. Alfred Prufrock is an old male with bald spot in the middle of the hair, low self esteem, and slight mental illness.
Speaker of the “My Last Duchess” is also a male, Ferrara. However, whole tone and attitude that living in his ‘own world’, and not to communicate with others but to just telling, are same as Alfred Prufrock. But he is really different from Alfred Prufrock.
Ferrara is not talking to audience, but other person. First Ferrara started to talk about how beautiful painting is (line 2~around 13), after that, he is talking about how his ex-wife was flirting with other people (line 13~ around 47), and lastly he is talking about his future wife (47~56). In the way he talks, tone, and word he used were all very dominating, and demanding. In line 45, he didn’t say he asked to his ex-wife but he chose word ‘commanded’ to his ex-wife. And I got feeling from Ferrara’s way of talking that he killed his ex-wife because of jealousy. And for me, his ex-wife seems like a lady with a nice, warm heart (line 21~23). But Ferrara took that in a wrong way. Also, it seems like Ferrara is more interested in money and power that future marriage will give him rather than his ‘future wife’ it selves. Because in line 54~55 he only talks about bronze Neptune with taming sea horse, rather than talking about his future wife. Overall, I think Ferrara’s characteristics are power demanding, arrogant (tone), dominating, cold hearted, and jealous.